Al-Ghazali’s Crisis and the Ihya’s Origins
By 1095 CE, Abu Hamid al-Ghazali (1058-1111 CE) was the most celebrated scholar in the Islamic world — occupying the Nizamiyya professorship in Baghdad, teaching hundreds of students, producing books on law, theology, and philosophy. Then he experienced a crisis of certainty: he realized that most of what he knew was formal, exterior knowledge, and that he himself was trapped in love of status and worldly recognition rather than genuine proximity to Allah.
He suffered a nervous breakdown — he could not speak or eat — and after months of paralysis, he left Baghdad secretly, leaving his wealth behind and embarking on a decade of travel and spiritual retreat. The Ihya’ was the product of this transformation: a man who had everything the religious academy offered, realized its insufficiency, discovered Sufi spiritual practice, and then wrote the definitive synthesis.
The Four Volumes — Architecture of the Ihya’
Volume 1 — Rub’ al-‘Ibadat (Acts of Worship)
The inner dimensions of external worship:
- The knowledge of the heart required to make prayer valid
- Dhikr and Quranic recitation as interior acts
- The states of mind (ahwal) in zakat and hajj
Al-Ghazali’s innovation: formal fiqh tells you what to do; the Ihya’ tells you what to be while doing it.
Volume 2 — Rub’ al-‘Adat (Social Customs and Conduct)
Islamic ethics of daily life:
- Eating, marriage, earning a livelihood
- Friendship, travel, commanding good and forbidding evil
- Listening to music (sama’) — his position: permissible if it stirs love of Allah
Volume 3 — Rub’ al-Muhlikat (Soul-Destroying Vices)
The diagnosis of the sick soul:
- Pride (kibr), envy (hasad), riya (ostentation), anger, love of the world, miserliness
- Each vice analyzed: its causes, its signs in behavior, its remedy
- The most famous chapter: on kibr (pride) — the original sin of Iblis
Volume 4 — Rub’ al-Munjiyat (Soul-Saving Virtues)
The path to the healthy soul:
- Tawba (repentance), sabr (patience), shukr (gratitude), fear and hope, zuhd (asceticism), tawakkul (trust in Allah), mahabbah (love), rida (contentment), muraqaba (watchfulness), marifa (gnosis)
- This volume is the most Sufi in character — the systematic path to Allah through the stations and states
The Controversy and the Resolution
Ibn al-Jawzi criticized the Ihya’ for relying on weak hadith — a legitimate textual critique. Al-Zubaydi (18th c.) wrote a ten-volume commentary (Ithaf al-Sada al-Muttaqin) identifying and authenticating the hadith.
The Maliki scholars of North Africa actually burned the Ihya’ briefly in the 12th century, concerned about its Sufi elements reaching the uneducated. But the work’s brilliance and comprehensiveness eventually overcame all opposition. Ibn Taymiyya — no friend of Sufism — still praised it as useful.
Connection to Ismaili Tradition
Al-Ghazali spent part of his decade of travel in Jerusalem and is known to have engaged with Ismaili and Fatimid philosophical literature (his Fadha’ih al-Batiniyya was a critique of Ismaili esotericism). Scholars note structural parallels between the Ihya’s hierarchical approach to spiritual knowledge and the Ismaili hierarchical da’wa structure — both posit that external worship points to deeper realities accessible through systematic inner work.
See also: Al Ghazali, Sulook, Marifa, Tawba Sincere Repentance, Dhikr, Akhlaq, Shukr, Fiqh Overview, Kalam, Haqiqa